Larian Studios Forums Baldur's Gate III Baldur's Gate III - Help Tips & Tricks Stuck at Shar's gauntlet - Shadowheart choices

Either I fight Shadowheart, losing her as a companion or I let her kill Nightsong, which isn't an appealing choice either. My character has CHA 18, but I have a 30 to roll to convince Shadowheart otherwise. Not even a perfect 20 could resolve this, since I only have 9 bonus points.

You do not have to persuade her to spare Aylin.

If your approval with Shadowheart is high and the narrator mentions that you've created a meaningful bond with her, then simply by not intervening and trusting her to make her own choice will cause her to throw the spear away.

if you leave the choice up to Shadowheart, she will make a decision in line with what you want without having to roll.