Well, I prefer in-game quests that actually make sense.
BUt, I do like the premise. Considering how it works with economy and resting, you can face every encounter at your full strength and I'd like to see a survival battle, where you'd have to carefuly keep an eye on your spell levels and other resources. That's the only challenge we really don't have yet, unless you force yourself to not rest as much. No 'imminent bomb' or other weird mechanic, just increasing waves of enemies; which you have to kill quick, or get overwhelmed.
So, maybe make it a 'Defend against the Absolute's Army' or somesuch, to buy time for the Flaming Fist to fortify a position. The objective is to survive 25 rounds whilst defending a point, but every round you can stay there, is a bonus, if you do, of course. This makes sense, because we're told that the way is clear after Act 2, becasue the Amry is on the March, yet, when we get to the city, it's all fine and everyone stays happily camping outside the walls. It'd be good to have an explanation for that, and this could be it. Now you have use for things liek Potion of Angelic Slumber *in combat*, can I do without my cleric for a few rounds? Alright, go and sleep, we'll defend you.
So, I'd say make an arena with increasingly difficult enemies coming in, with no resting in between. Big map with hiding spots, elevation, destructible wooden towers and platforms and a number of spawn points.
In come a handful of gobbos at first, better kill them quick, becasue Ogres join their number, then Drow, then more gobbos with hobgoblins, then a Beholder with Mindflayers, a Bulette makes a comeback, minotaurs join the fray with soldiers backing them up and even more gobbos to throw arrows at you using up your precious reactions. They get Mage Backup, and cultists from each of the Three....
That would be epic. Just like everythinbg else, it'd be optional, of course, but it'd be nice if you see this reflected in the final battle as well. Skip this quest, but have a way harder time at the end if you do.
Last edited by rodeolifant; 05/09/23 12:47 PM.