Larian Studios Forums Baldur's Gate III Baldur's Gate III - Technical & Gameplay Problems Durge Act 1 Dialogue Problems (Spoilers?)

I have a question about Act 1 with the Durge. Now with the Durge you have the option to tell your companions about your Lack of Memories and/or Your Lust for Blood but when you do your First ...Sleep Murder? You still have the option to tell them about your memories problems even if you told them about it before hand and if told them about your bloodlust as well they react the same.

Also if you talk about them your Bloodlust after you get the same responses as if you talked to them before it.
Add to the fact if you tell them you murdered the girl, you still get the option to tell them that you didn't. Are these bugged triggers? or just bad dialogue flow?

To share your worries about your bloodlust and memory loss - is unique one-time appears dialogues lines for each of your companions. If you have selected this dialog option, it will disappear from the list of options (that's how it should be).
The dialogue after murder of an innocent - provides the option to lie, or tell the truth.
It's different, independent dialogue tree.
Why does the game give you the opportunity to lie, even when you have told about your thirst for blood? Because logically, bloodlust alone does not make you a murderer. As your companions say: it's one thing to have a bloodlust, but it's quite another to follow it.

This isn't what i'm talking about at all.

1. You murder the Girl, you choose remember/investigate. This finds you murdered the girl.
2. You can choose to Hide the body, clean the blood from yours hands, wait till everyone wakes up or just go back to sleep.
3. In the morning your companions wake up. Now during this dialogue you can tell them about how you have no memory of anything, not just the murder. The problem is this dialogue about having memory loss still comes up if you already told them about this before. (So them about the memory loss shouldn't be an option, it's just repeating.)
4. During this morning dialogue you can lie about if you killed the girl or not. But even if you choose to tell the truth about everything. When you next talk to your companions a dialogue option will come up saying "I don't care what you think I didn't murder her
", which conflicts if you already confessed to the murder. This dialogue will only go away if you use it. (In other words this dialogue shouldn't appear at all if you choose to tell them the truth.)
5. The conversation about the bloodlust is fine if you talk to them before the the murder but if talk to them after the murder all of them act as if it's still normal and nothing to be worried about. This doesn't make sense at all because they have seen what happens when your bloodlust gets out of control and to the fact talking about this after the murder happens and you lying about the murdering her also would raise questions about if you killed her or not.

I pretend it means "I didn't kill her on purpose" if i play Durge who confessed to doing it, but it's probably an oversight/bug.


Durge storyline was rushed and it's obvious.

Very Obvious, to the point for someone like me. It's unplayable. I like Durge but the amount of stuff you have to turn a blind eye to story wise is painful. I guess I'll go back to playing Tav again.