Larian Studios

When I choose response (1.) in a triggered cutscene with Shadowheart “Option is no longer valid” appears in red in the upper left of the screen. I have to choose (2. Leave) to continue. This scene automatically triggers in the Gnome windmill area when Shadowheart gets near a statue around the back of the windmill. It’s where she gets sudden pain in her hand. I think this is an error because I think I had this scene already trigger a little earlier elsewhere.

The dialogue is broken if she hasn’t told you that she’s a follower of Shar yet. If you want the dialogue to work, I would recommend going to the owlbear cave and checking out the shrine to Selune. Then open up the chest there. She’ll angrily tell you that the Moon Witch’s trinkets are probably cursed. And you can do an insight check I believe and ask her why she cares so much. She’ll tell you then that she serves Shar. Then statue dialogue should work!