It shouldn't really matter what you get. The tags mostly give you special dialogue options, that may help you getting certain people to trust you, for example the Outlaw tag will probably make it easier to persuade thieves etc. Other than that, it may also change how you interact with specific items, but they mostly just add another way to solve a quest, and quests have a lot of ways to be solved.
So just pick whatever you think would fit your character and see what the game offers you.