This is a fine skill, my beef is requiring it on more than one character. (Required being, completionist approach to all available quests in games.) Ifan has it, so I've been using him. Oh, wait, Sir Lora is too snooty to speak with Ifan so now I need Pet Pal on my main who is Noble (which I haven't done because other things are too valuable for character building). Oh wait, now I need a Pet Pal on the Red Prince in order to open a chest because once again a damn animal is too picky to speak with Ifan.
I'd be fine with this Pet Pal thing if I could treat it like loremaster: one and done. How frustrating would it be to need to level loremaster across the party in order to identify things? Because that is what the current Pet Pal set-up feels like.