Larian Studios Forums Baldur's Gate III Baldur's Gate III - Suggestions & Feedback One always lies...

A twist on the popular, childhood "Two Knights" riddle.



It would be nice if two things would happen because of that link:

1- Allow me to fully flesh out any/all dialog trees before putting me in a position to take a quest. This isn't the first time it's happened, but it's the one that is the most issue inducing.
2- Actually put a form of the answer to this riddle in one of the dialog trees that I can (eventually) reach before making my choice on who to attack.

Accepting to do something doesn't behold you to do it unless you really want to play a lawful character or what you accepted happens right in the next dialogue prompt.

The whole point of that quest, like every other quests in the game, is to role-play your character and roll with the consequences of your decisions. That specific quest has hidden DC checks in conversation. Not having all the information to resolve it is entirely on purpose and

What would really be nice is if people would really exhaust all possible means of resolving an issue before they come to the forums claiming there wasn't a satisfactory way to resolve it.


What's even funnier about this is the loading screen tip that explains that you can do this in game.

There was two guards standing before gate, and giant sign abowe them with text:
"One always tell the truth, other one always lies."

Mage: Ok, this one is tricky ... we need to think it trough.
Barbarian kills one with his axe.
Mage: WTF?
Barbarian: Is he dead?
Guard: No.
Barbarian: I found a liar!