What about Critdamage for the whole game, when i on purpose let my Eye taken by Hag or similar Volo and lose Critdamage.
As a Rogue depending on it to compete after level 5 with Great Weapon users, whole concept is a mess then.
What then?
I don't know what you mean. Maybe, you wanna elaborate.
Regardless, tho, according to PHB combat maneuver damage die should be involved in crit damage calculation rules. The rule is very simple and clear, all damage dice should be rolled twice. Rogue or fighter, it doesn't matter.