Well I finally settled on a winner.
I took the amulet and this is what I got
charm 4
constitution 8
defense 5
vitality 100
magic 100
fire resistance 10
ligthning resistance 20
spirit resistance 15
sight 3
hearing 3
restoration 1
This ended up being better than my best dagger because with the amulet I had 2 more charm slots. The resistances where another reason I went with the amulet.
Thanks for your input Raze.
