Halo was cool 2, B&W was... overrated indeed
Don't mistake "Gamespy's 25 worst games of all times" and "Gamespy's 25 most overrated Games of All Times". If NWN or Black and White or Alice or... is in the list it DOES NOT mean it is a bad game, ok? It means that it was overhyped.
Black and White WAS overhyped. Look at all the cover stories written about it.
And look at the number of B&W players today.
NWN WAS over hyped (check the box: "the only game you'll ever need... the game which will change everything...")
Halo WAS overhyped: it was "the game" and PC Mags cried when they learned that it will be 'Xbox Xclusive' but look at it now: it's far from being the most original game.
