but they could see that others have dots too on the first day..
SO i dont get it :S
why would they only draw the conclusion on the 3rd day?
on the first day, they saw no one jumped, and also saw that according to you, 2 other monks had a dot.
He could immediatly draw the conclusion that he has a dot himself then according to you, but the other monks don't know about their own dots eiter.
Confused <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/confused.gif" alt="" />
