Raze
>>If conditional questions that can not be answered (thus providing information) with a yes or no do not count as questionsI never said the question doesn't count as question... I said the whole sentence is
one question, and not two, as you stated.
"If A and B are different, is A a liar?" <- Is this one question or two?
-> Answer me this question: "If A and B are different?"
<img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/confused.gif" alt="" />
The only really misleading aspect I see is the "yes or no" questions: however, the fact that they are questions that can only be answered by yes or no, doesn't rule out they simply
can't be answered.
Compare it to a paradox. Maybe you know this one:
On a card there are 3 statements.
----------------------------------
a. This sentence has five words.
b. This sentence has two verbs.
c. Exactly one sentence on this card is true.
----------------------------------
Question: is statement c true or false?Do we agree that the question is a "true or false" question? Altering the question a bit, even turns it into a "yes or no" question:
----------------------------------
Question: Is statement c true?----------------------------------
So there, I've asked a yes or no question. But can you answer it?
*** Visit 
