This is how I see the good vs. evil situation:
Judgement 1: The Imp tortured people. For causing suffering he deserves to die. [color:"green"]Divine Justice = Good.[/color] [color:"red"]Revenge = Evil.[/color]
Judgement 2: The Imp was forced to torture people against his will. For non having such intensions himself, he should be spared. [color:"green"]Forgiveness = Good.[/color] For not standing up to his opressors, he should be weeded out of the evolutionary cycle. [color:"red"]Enforced Darwinism = Evil.[/color]
Judgement 3: The Imp knows about Samuel and may prove a useful ally. [color:"green"]Befriending = Good.[/color] [color:"red"]Using for personal gain = Evil.[/color]
Judgement 4: The Imp makes for good combat training. [color:"red"]Manslaughter = Evil.[/color]
Judgement 5: The Imp has nice boots. [color:"red"]Armed Robbery = Evil.[/color]
Judgement 6: The Imp is a living creature. He should be alowed to live whatever his ideals. [color:"green"]Acceptance = Good.[/color] Let's kill it! [color:"red"]Destruction = Evil.[/color]
That's how I see it. Any other Judgements on poor Ploxy?