I would say go for IWD gold. Both games are immense fun and have the right proportions of action/RPG for me. Also if you don't play D2 online then you'll get bored of the SP mode fairly quickly.
And anyone who thinks D2 is a simple clickfest should try teleporting through the durance of hate lvl 2 on hell mode with a 700hp sorc. I'm sick of reading that type if gibberish. The game requires skill, cunning and tactics, especially if you're duelling....
Oh and SP WC3 is immense fun and will make you pull your hair out at times! There is an orc campaign for download now that is sort of RPG/action oriented. It comes with the latest patch I believe, you can just log onto Bnet.
I'm off to play Sacred myself. <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" />
Potatoe
