Well, I have a totally different problem with "Josie". I don't care what she throws at me--Hellspikes barely scratch me, Death Knights are no match for me.
My problem with Josie is that when i have nearly Killed Her she opens a Portal and escapes--"Poof* she is Gone. This has happened 4 times now and I "thought" this is what she is "Supposed" to do so I just moved on and forgot about it.
Then after reading this and all you people saying how you DID kill her--I don't get it. Why then does She merely open the Portal and escape Every time I have nearly Killed Her? Oh,and If I go through the Portal also,thinking that I will follow her all I do is end up back on the Entry level,and She is nowhere to be seen.