I played both Gothic and Sacred... Gothic 2 was DEMO but it showed great potential! Sacred is too much Hack-n-Slash, and I don't like these kind of games... I like RPGs with good story, great mechanism and what is most important, good ROLE PLAY!!! Between these two games, certain winner is Gothic 2!

Btw. What is DSA? Never heard of thing? Where to find more info about the game?