I've slain Barnabus and I've been using his mace ever since. It's easily and by far the best weapon i've come accross in the game.
I thought his ring was to be proof of his death, but actually it turns out to be his mace!!
I do want to complete the hunter's quest, as it delivers 100GS achievement, but i also do not want to loose the mace. Is there a way I can have both? At at what point in the game will I not be able to go back to turn in the quest ?
For now, I'll hang on the mace and not turn in the quest...
-shocked-