One one hand, I think that the review was too harsh. When the game worked - it was a hell of alot of fun to play. But my 360 version developed a game killing save bug which completely wrecked the game. So, though I think the game was better than the rewiew in many ways I have to aggree with his conclusion on the 360 version. Until the save bug is fixed no one should buy the 360 version of the game - it in many cases simply does not work. Infact, Microsoft should recall the game or put a patch out immediately. I am still attonished that Xbox would release a game with this kind of game killing bug in it.