Thanks. Other than the math appendix, Kiya, Barnabus and Myrthos did most of the work on the guide.
Even if we had access to the detailed mechanics behind combat calculations when we were making the guide, I doubt many people would be that interested.
Besides, it really is quite playstyle dependent. I played somebody else's save with 2 warriors, both high strength/damage and low speed/agility/accuracy. They lost a quest item and had trouble with the 'lost items' procedure, so I replaced it for them and then played a bit to confirm the quest could be completed, burning through potions along the way to get through an area. I returned the save and suggested they improve their agility and get their survival/speed up some, but they replied that they were not having any trouble with combat, so would stick with what they were doing.
