Yes semi-random loot is good but 100% random is bad though, how would you like it if you could get one of the best random-able item in game from the chest in Farglow and an apple with the same chance of both, and the same for every other chest & item in game?

You need to put weightings on the chests etc so you dont end up with a lvl 2 with a full set of uber equipment that he/she cant use.