Quote
I'm not the one that was looking for meaning in the quest.

Really? You're the one who giving a detailed suggestion-"explanation" about that, but at the same time you say: "I played through that section without giving it too much analysis".
Fun.
Illogical statements is soo illogical.

Quote
So rather than argue the facts you attack the source?

No, did you miss my point? The point is: I can't trust any source that was somehow corrected AFTER the game was released.
"Hey guys, there is some errors I found in D2 plot/settings, let's fix it in new releases (USA/russian). Wait, the german version is out already... oh well, poor guys, but who cares".
If the devs itself can't be sure about their creation even AFTER the release I see no reason to be sure in it as well.
You know what fact is? A transcendental, solid-state thing you can operate with, to make some conslusions, result thoughts. You can't operate with facts that suddenly changes (it is not the fact then) like you can't hold water in your arms.
Simple logic.

Quote
Any changes to D2:ED's plotline are irrelevant to how old Ygerna was.[/quoite]
Fun, but I didn't make any connections between such aspects, it was you did it right now.
>_>
<_<

[quote]My point was that the two different resurrection methods were not necessarily inconsistent.

Good, I see you don't deny the fact that you still accept a gameplay element (how you say? ah, "event". Event within a game plot, mmk) as the plot's/setting's one and even compare it to another which is -- no doubt -- a really plot-related "event", because it's the main quest and plot-line since the beginning of the game.
I see that such comprasion make no sense.
I wonder what fans see here...

Quote
Well, how could I refute such a reasoned and logical argument as that?

You know what I find hilarious (it's related, yes)? The fact of existing such thread. No-no, you don't need to count a ppl opinions there, I already did it for you: the amount of ppl who likes DAO is much bigger, which I find hilarious, especially consider the fact it is a DIVINITY forums.
But that's not the point. The point is: count how many times ppl who like DAO uses word like plot, story. Then count the same words used by ppl who like D2 and compare.

Ofc I now the results. They... symbolizes.

"Just my opinion" yeah, lol.


Joram
Quote
Wait ... See ... Play Flames of Vengeance ... and make your conclusion !

You know why I like Piranha Bytes guys (and their games ofc)? Because if they made something bad or wrong in previous game they gonna fix/improve it in the next one coz feel ashamed of that. Like it was with Gothic 3 - a pure bugdrome. And look at Risen - almost no bugs, compare to their other games.

I hope Larian guys will do everything to fix a mess. In the end, Belgium not so far from German, it must be in their blood! :P