I vote unmodded: DAO, TDKS, then OB (hated it)
modded: OB (hands down, beats any other game out there for me), DAO, TDKS (no modding unfortunately)

Grafix: TDKS, OB (unmodded), DAO
Combat: (biggest distinction is DAO is continuous turn based, OB and TDKS are real time)
-DAO is much more tactical and strategic
-OB has more involved combat (i like active blocking and having to manuever around each fight and not just click to win, and a mod in OB made it the best combat game i have ever played), TDKS felt like 3d Diablo to me, very hack and slashy
Story:
-DAO, OB, not done with TDKS yet :P
Replayability/Longevity
-I couldnt play vanilla OB in disgust, modded OB only left my PC when my HD went bust (thousands of hours of gameplay
- DAO gave me hundreds of hours, each playthru much more distinct from the others than OB
-TDKS potentially great replayability from the sheer combination of skills but i see myself only playing fighter then mage

Last edited by SonOfCapiz; 18/11/10 07:58 PM.
Can a mother forget the baby at her breast and have no compassion on the child she has borne? Though she may forget, I will not forget you. See, I have engraved you on the palms of my hands... - Isaiah 49:15-16