Actually, the only RPG (R for role) here is DA. All others is some kind of... imposters.
I simply can't agree with what you said Kein

But I'm afraid this can be an
endless discussion about WHAT are real Role Playing Games and WHEN is a game a RPG ?
For me a game is a RPG when it has at least:
1)
Skills and statpoints the gamer can invest per level he/she gained
2) Via killing monsters etc and solving quests your hero
collect XP points for leveling-up
3)
Quests (main quests + side quests) to solve
4)
Weapons and armor and other loot to find/equip to make your hero stronger (fever)
5) And last but not least,of course, a nice/funny/ ...
story !
Nice atmosphere and music (and more) are welcome extra's to make each rpg fun !
So for me all Divinity games (and many other games) are REAL RPG's !!