Now this is a topic!
I usually go the way of the goodie-two-shoes (if that's how it's written) unless these two things happen:
1: The evil path gives me an item that is an upgrade for me and/or gives me significantly more exp. (Loot-Whore)
2: The evil path gives me an achievement or something I can't get without going down that path. (Completionist)
Even though I have these two rules sometimes it breaks my heart going against my morals. I've spent plenty of time in many games pondering over my decisions and searching the internet for a conclusion that is the least painful for my moral heart. Strangely enough my morals are nowhere to be found in some of the same situation in real life. Guess it's because I can't see other peoples side as clearly as I can in games
