I loved the puzzles and the lack of direction. One thing i would have liked though was a description of where npc's i had finished quests for were located. I don't want gps arrows and i don't need them marked on my map, i would like a like line of text in my journal though. For example "I found the sword john was looking for, i should return it to him at the red dragon inn." Not just "I should find john and return it."
This was not a huge issue for me, but there were a couple of npcs i just couldn't for the life of me remember where i had met. I ran around quite a bit in aleroth trying to find some npc's, since there were so many there.
