Is there any way to kick Tilian's butt for what he's done and avenge Saul? I have been doing this quest as follows and it bothers me every time:
I mindread Tilian to get the Chalice and go free Saul. The other option is totally out of the question for my character. I want to punish Tilian, not Saul. With the note from Kenneth recommending Saul, I feel like I'm missing something by not utilizing that note.

I'd like to close by quoting Bellegar's famous last rhyme:

"Cursed be the mother that bred thee!
The wench must have been a hell-spawned banshee!"