"All best game ever" for me depends on the following thing (it plop up in my mind this morning, so suddenly wink ) :
The best game ever for me is that kind of game (I play always RPG's, in the past more "adventures") that sweets my playstyle best !
So this is my personal "testcase" to say that game I give 4/10, the other 7/10 and so on ... but I prefer to say it in words : good, fantastic, a gem, etc ...

The thing is that the Divinity games are so far the ones that suits my RPG style best !
The first things I look at in a RPG are : Skills & Spells + skill system, Quests, how to build-up-my hero (stats & gear/equipment), lootsystem, story, replayability, NPC's, music, alchemy & other kind of RPG elements (crafting, enchanting, charms...), combatsystem, ...
And last but not least the "atmosphere" in a game. A game full of Fantasy takes more often my attention than a RPG that's (for example) almost like in real life! Like the enemies are : I prefer to kill Goblins and other monsterious creatures above killing (innocent) humans/women/children !

So on each RPG element I have my own preferences and graphics are mostly less important in comparing with the most basic RPG elements !

Following RPG's that make my attention (so far) are :
TES V Skyrim, Kingdoms of Alamur : Reckoning, Hunted: the Demon's Forge, The Witcher II, Diablo III, Dark Souls, ... and more .... and for sure last but not least Larian's new projects D & E !!

EDIT :and at home some RPG's are still waiting at me : Risen (level 10 or so now), Arcania (level 5), Two Worlds II (just started) and maybe I forget one ...

Last edited by Joram; 15/06/11 12:01 PM. Reason: see EDIT
On 7th of february 2015 : I start a new adventure in the Divinity world of Original Sin,
it's a Fantastic Freaking Fabulous Funny ... it's my All Time Favorite One !