With a new weapon:

(Magical) Sorcerer's Magical Heavy Iron Warhammer of Destruction
Melee Damage: 2-3
Magic Damge: 19-24
Critical Chance: 5%
+4 Intelligence
Empty Charm Slot
Increased Magical Damage: 20

Completely stripped down with only this hammer on my character that has 107% Magic Damage and all deafult 1s in weapon skills:

Melee: 2-3
M Melee: 42-44
Critical: 5%

Adding a Light Battle, Regular Metal, or Light Nightbringer shield with no Int boosts:

Melee: 2-3
M Melee: 61-67
Critical: 2.5%

The one thing I noticed is that all these shields are (Heroic) and in green font.