I have found all the secrets within Broken Valley with out help but for the life of me, I cannot get this dude out of the hole and I could use a bit of help.
The thing is - I have rope. I have twelve bloody ropes in my inventory. I walk up to Rothman and I am asked if I have rope. I do but the only option I am giving is:
'I don't have rope yet.'
and
'I got salt and pepper.'
I cannot find a 'beam' which to tie the rope to in order to get him out. Could someone help me? Its driving me nuts.