You did good declining willy. He's just trying to rip you off.
I didn't think it mattered much who you choose for the tower. Their quests will be different but it pretty much adds up to the same result. Say for instance if you choose Igor instead of the other guy (necromancer) he'll give more creature points to magic instead of melee, but your creature will still be awesome if you have perfect parts.
I choosed Wesson over Radcliffe. Even though Radcliffe's sword was better I just felt sorry for his wife :P
