The conversation at the bridge with the drunken guards got wierd, as Roderick ended up arguing with himself.
I started the conversation as Scarlet, and when they mentioned the wizard, I chose...sounds like a good idea!
Roderick then interrupted, with his three choices followed by "We'll do it your way". I believe I chose No, it might get the townsfolk against us (reason).
But then, Roderick spoke three choices again in arguement with himself. I think I chose the charm option.
Either way though, after Scarlet said the wizard was a good idea as her first choice, all the remaining lines were attributed to Roderick.