Just because you don't like how some things implemented in the game doesn't mean it they are [implemented] bad.
No one in this thread is saying anything is implemented poorly. In fact, if anything can or should be taken from this thread it's that people LIKE the combat and they want more of it. People have only thrown out suggestions or wish lists; no demands as you state in another comment.
This forum is for feedback. And that is what it is being used for. If you disagree, that's fine. But really, please calm down and at least discuss why you disagree outside of "I like it how it is." How would this break the game mechanics? How would this detract from gameplay? How would this ruin the experience if the devs can do it properly?
Just because you don't like a suggestion, that doesn't mean it's bad.
