Originally Posted by Hiver

There is nothing "rude" in calling something badly written - badly written Stabbs.
But there is something rude in calling things that are not rude - rude.


He was posting a paraphrase and his own personal interpretation of the conversation. He was not suggesting or demanding Larian write the dialogue exactly like that.

There was literally no point in calling it "badly written dialogue", and following up with "laughably bad" except for your need to snipe at and belittle other posters.

You WERE being rude, for no reason at all, and the fact that you don't even recognize that is a problem you should work on.

That's all I'm going to say about this.


Originally Posted by Hiver
Therefore as point 1. I should have the option of just leaving money to him.
Instead - i am forced to take it away in one of the three ways, which all lead into RPS minigame.
One of the three choices is to argue he should give money to Berthia to pay her for her sheep he stole and used.

If a player chooses that option - it means he wants that to happen - specifically.

You win the RPS and go to see Berthia. When you start talking to her THERE IS NO OPTION ABOUT GIVING HER MONEY AT ALL!!!

Thats whats wrong, among other things.


(Today, I actually lost the minigame and Roberts kept the money.)

I do think that clicking Robert's topic "About the money you received..." should have a "Never mind." option to let you back out.

And I agree, there should be a dialogue to offer Bertia the money up front, and that should change the quest's outcome.