For some reason this really hit home with me last evening creating a new party. I think there should just be a screenshot of the players mug you create. Perhaps what would be extra cool if we were be able control zoom in and and angle to make it unique (Xbox Live Style). And if you want to go for the grand slam, have a Oil Painting effect you can apply for those who like the painted look.
That said, not expecting anything, but if just a mug of your actual character... I would prefer that and then you have millions of combo's.
Rank - Low, Nice to Have.
