Stop metagaming and try to get immersed in the game.
A totally nonsensical statement and/or argument. The whole point of RPG's is to make a good character. If you are intentionally missing out on hugely beneficial traits as a result of "being immersed" then its stupid. And I find it breaking the immersion to get something I DON'T want for giving an answer I did want.
The rogue can pickup a + 20% chance to hit on backstab early from vindictive. But that's only if you answer right. Same for the lucky charm example stated above.
I like the idea of this, but it does fail because you will get skill bonuses you don't care about for your specific character.
