I'm not sure. AJ may surprise us and really dig the game. He might not appreciate all the nuances someone more familiar with the genre would... yet perhaps he'd really like the combat and elemental stuff, or enjoy the freedom of the game, or get off on the possibility of going on a murder spree after stealing everything not nailed down in a village...
I certainly wouldn't rely on him, or any single source, to form my opinion on D:OS or any game, yet he usually provides at least some good insights into whatever he reviews.
