Excuse my language above, i just had to vent a little bit after being repeatedly shot at by enemies standing in or behind smoke clouds or some ordinary assets in nature - that i cannot shoot back at.
....
from a different playthrough:
In Silverglen Tavern, after finishing with Bicky situation in a positive way, (i get the reputation positive points and all), my two characters get the dialogue prompt overhead and comment the situation as if ive chosen the worse option.
If i do choose the worse thing then there is no dialogue prompt and nobody comments anything.
I do lose a few points of rep in the whole group though.