Two Handed Broad Axe. Item Level 12. 66-167 Damage.
Blacksmithing 1: Not Enough Blacksmithing.
Blacksmithing 2: 76-192 Damage.
Blacksmithing 3: 76-192 Damage.
Blacksmithing 4: 76-192 Damage.
Blacksmithing 5: 86-218 Damage.
Blacksmithing 6: 86-218 Damage.
Blacksmithing 7: 86-218 Damage.
Blacksmithing 8: 86-218 Damage.
Blacksmithing 9: 86-218 Damage.
Mercygiver. Item Level 13. 43-72 Damage.
Blacksmithing 1: Not Enough Blacksmithing.
Blacksmithing 2: 49-82 Damage.
Blacksmithing 3: 49-82 Damage.
Blacksmithing 4: 49-82 Damage.
Blacksmithing 5: 49-82 Damage (Did not increase when the axe did!).
Blacksmithing 6: 49-82 Damage.
Blacksmithing 7: 49-82 Damage.
Blacksmithing 8: 49-82 Damage.
Blacksmithing 9: 49-82 Damage.
Definitely something hinky going on at Blacksmithing 5.