Why is everyone so hyped about this game and why o why does this game have a 9/10 score on gamespot, metacritic etc? Not to insult the game dev hours of work but there are to many sloppy things in the game.
For instance, the story is so fragmented and so contradictive that it makes the entire thing hard to follow or understand, the UI is mediocre and the features are nothing spectacular.

Now, I know how that sounded and I can back that not only with words but also proof but I first want someone to tell me if I am missing something and not getting the big picture because it's rather difficult to play through the entire game in order to get a proper opinion.

P.S. I just love turn based games so that's why I am asking.