There seems to be a lot of personal drive behind your reasoning. Although you've been met with some valid counter-arguments, you prefer to think that anyone else just misunderstood you.
The principle of a discussion like this is to get your point across to someone else.
It's up to you to convince someone else, not everyone else to try and understand you.
If you feel people aren't getting what you mean, try rephrasing and keep the blame away.
We aren't out to hurt you, you aren't out to hurt us.
Not sure what you aim to achieve when you wrote "point" so boldly, but it sure isn't going to convince us that you actually have a point. That rests in your ability to convey your message.

In regards to the topic, on a whole, it will never work and only promise demise.
I'm not going to repeat all the reasons why, they've been covered by multiple posters already.
If your method would work, it would have been applied a long time ago.
Look at how DLC forced itself into the market. Only casuals liked the idea, but most never seemed to have grasped what it would end up as. A pile of shit that people still pay for.

[MOD] Reworked Madora and Jahan