Somehow I find the "good" cloth maps in your examples too perfect. I mean it looks too manufactered, done by machines. Small thread, perfect tight pattern, perfectly cut edges...
Sure I don't expect Larian to handcraft 10K or more cloth maps for the CEs, but I'd rather not have something so perfect, clean, smooth and modern that it doesn't look like an old map but rather like a printed handkerchied someone would use to clean their glasses.
You never have seen the DOS1 'cloth map' right? A piece of plastic fabric that you could use equally well as a handkerchief as some yoghurt pot. The DA:O cloth map is most likely still superior to the DOS1 cloth map
Besides that, a bigger, better cloth map for me is fine, something that I can actually frame and hang on my the wall without getting into trouble with my wife sounds like an excellent item for collectors edition. Something that I can add to my collection of art and enjoy.
