I think all the other games I have on xbox are server based, I can't think of any other peer to peer games I have except for Divinity, with that being said we did try and play without our routers hooked up and it still was not letting me join. Both me and my friend have comcast so I don't know if it might be a problem with our ISP. Thank you tho for the response and I hope something is found on this issue!
