Hello, I am just a couple of achievements away from getting all achievements done but like so many others, the Sister of Mercy achievement with the Revenge of the Source Hunter quest eludes me.
YES, I have done tons of searches, YES I have followed those supposed success stories / guides posted by the tiny few who got it, YES I have followed Raze's guide posts about what dialogue options to choose throughout the game, YES I have chosen every option and still when Madora confronts Norok she refuses to forgive him. So please don't tell me about the 5 minimum dialogue checks etc - I have read all the guides, chosen the stated correct options for a lot more than 5 dialogues so I should have been more than safe in my choices.
So what I am hoping for is some kind of acknowledgement from Larian that the achievement is indeed bugged, or at least a little too strict and possibly something they are working on in a future patch to make a little easier to achieve, or at least more transparent / logically attainable.
I am sure most will understand how this one achievement becomes a depressing stumbling block when one has completed every other achievement including beating the game on honor mode - but is forced to do another 40/50/60 hour playthrough just for this one achievement.
Not saying I am not eager to do yet another playthrough - I love this game, but after my tense honor run I would prefer a relaxed tactician run without worrying whether I've screwed up a single dialogue option with Madora along the way, or worrying about any other achievements.