You say repeatedly not to dismiss you and then type several times you followed the steps exactly, "except"......do you see the problem.....no? I'll give you a minute.
Before taking offense to my dismissal of your dismissal of a proven correct solution, ask a friend that you trust to read your posts.
Look, I am not trying to be mean, I am being as diplomatic as I can; your posts are incorrect and not helpful as your information is simply wrong. Stop posting incorrect information and I will stop "dismissing" you
Allow me to repeat myself yet again - I did not say following the list exactly would not get you the achievement, my argument is that at least one of those checks is incorrect and I proved it.
Clearly you stopped reading my post at the first line, after 'EXCEPT'. So I am done with you, you simply can't think or argue logically and actually be bothered to read my argument. As is typical of many forum arguments, you conveniently skip over most of my post and any valid points I made.
May whoever actually reads this thread in its entirety find my *correct* information useful and understand why they may be missing the achievement if they miss even a single dialogue check, or like me decide NOT to kill Victoria - because doing so shuts out other quests. Simply changing the Hiberheim snow warden check will give players some more breathing room on getting enough dialogue checks, because I without a doubt proved by save/reloading that at least THAT dialogue check is incorrect. Clearly a piece of useful information, hmm?
So to all players reading, simple fact :
If you want the achievement but don't want to kill Victoria (understandably to not miss out on other quests such as Staff of Pergamon from the Mayor)... follow 'The List' exactly but change the Hiberheim snow warden check because it is incorrect
Then you will get the bare minimum checks to get the achievement
