That goes both ways, my guys also have two overshields, as you call them, by now

I actually liked having both a physical armour bar and a magical one visible. The rouge, if correctly positioned, deals horrible amounts of damange anyway and seems to bypass armour (or is crits dealing so much damage?) that I haven't considered armour a problem. Having magical shield on the roughe though is neccessary, since he needs to be able to cross areas that might stun him otherwise.