So what you're saying is : don't add any kind of system to make sure everyone gets some loot, just let the party discuss the matter and choose its member wisely ?
Kind of... But it is more that rolling/instanced doesn't solve the underlying problem... it only aggravates it.
If you need rolling/instancing then your party is broken with or without it.
Which is kind of funny... Because the only ones who could actually use rolling or instancing are the people who absolutely do not need it.
Rolling/instancing is a false solution that if told to someone they might say "Ohh that seems fair" or they might even think it would solve the problem... But really it only adds fuel to the fire.
If you want to find an alternative way to solve the problem go ahead. I am only pointing out that this solves nothing. You saw a open wound and you decided to put a blanket over it and call it fixed.
