I'm pretty confused about this, because I don't understand if it's a bug or if it's supposed to be this way.
Most of the time only one of us receives experience for party quest conversations in coop. Like, the other player(s) literally have to leave the game completely if we want the same amount of experience on all party members.
"Share" in the quest log doesn't do anything, because these quests already are in "party quests" category. For example, Griff and his "oranges". It 100% was a party quest, we both had it in our logs and "share" was ticked, we were both engaged in the conversation (there was a party decision in it), but Griff just wouldn't give any XP to the other player.
It would make sense if we had a competition and sneakily tried to complete quests without waiting for each other (and that's certainly a fun option), but this wasn't what we wanted to do. We were trying to pull off a partnership scenario. We received the quest together, we did it together, we turned it in together, but only one of us got XP in the end.
I find that slightly annoying.

Last edited by Aldaron O'Shrew; 18/05/17 05:10 PM.