Larian Banner: Baldur's Gate Patch 9
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Joined: Jan 2009
Stabbey Offline OP
veteran
OP Offline
veteran
Joined: Jan 2009
In the patch notes there was briefly a mention of the Zombie Talent being removed for "mysterious reasons".

Silames on the Steam forums wonders if that means Zombie will become the undead racial Talent.

Now, I don't have any evidence that this will be the case, especially not that the line has been removed from the patch notes, but in case it is correct, I want to strongly suggest that this should not happen.


Who here has used the Zombie Talent in D:OS 2? Was it in a party of all Zombies, or one Zombie in a group of regular characters?

***

From the start of the beta, Zombie has been terrible as a serious perk. Bedrolls were instant death. Any points into the Necromancer ability hurt you. Zombie Elves eating flesh got hurt. Blessed surfaces, like those which mysteriously appear after certain combats hurt. The steam around Amadia's waypoint in the seeker shrine hurt.

And those were just the UNintended side effects.

The intentional ones are that all normal healing damages you, so you are RESTRICTED to healing from poison and ONLY poison. Poison is an extremely rare healing effect, appearing only in the Geomancer tree, which forces all Zombies into picking Geo.

Poison appears often in combat, which leads to the big intended downside. Poison is highly flammable, and in combat it often ends up exploding unintentionally. That is what you have to stand in to heal. Enemies are smart enough to target poison and blow it up.

Because of their need for poison and weakness to healing, Zombies are best suited for a party of 4 Zombies. Mixing them in with regular people leaves everyone unhappy.

Whoops, the whole battlefield of water and blood is poison now, sorry regular humans. Whoops, my Healing Ritual spell to save the three of us zapped the Zombie really good.

Making Zombie the Undead Racial Talent (and presumably removing it from the regular list) means that a mixed party is the only way to play a Zombie, which makes it untenable.

Zombie might be fun for a gimmick 4-Zombie playthrough, but it is such a severe burden to deal with that if Zombie becomes the Undead Racial Talent, that will make the entire race basically unfun and unplayable.

Lots of people were enthusiastic to play as the Undead race, but making it an obnoxious chore by forcing a Talent with such an obnoxious and severe downside onto them is a terrible move.

Please, Larian, for the sake of all that is good and holy: Don't sabotage and kill the Undead race with a misguided idea.

Last edited by Stabbey; 26/05/17 02:13 AM. Reason: tweaks
Joined: Apr 2017
D
enthusiast
Offline
enthusiast
D
Joined: Apr 2017
In D:OS 1 you can in theory steam roll through the game with 4 zombies and the npc would not care one second that you are undead.

I would be fine with the removal of the zombie talent,simply because it is one of the strongest talents in the game.

On the flip side however,I think it would be fun if both custom undead and origin undead would get a source skill which permanently adds the zombie talent to your target,but can not be cast on characters who already have this talent.

Joined: Oct 2016
journeyman
Offline
journeyman
Joined: Oct 2016
I despise this. In every way. Zombie as a talent is FINE. So what if there are a few gimmicky talents that never get picked up. Like 5 Star Diner? Worthless. 4-Party Zombie play throughs are hilarious. Don't take this away from me. They finally added a deathly pale human skin color, and now they want to take away my zombie talent? Fuck that.

Joined: Jan 2009
Stabbey Offline OP
veteran
OP Offline
veteran
Joined: Jan 2009
If Larian needs an Undead Racial Talent, how about something like this:

Resilient Body
Gain 5 Physical armor per level.

At level 30 that's an extra 150 armor. Numbers can be adjusted as needed, but that seems like an okay starting point. Maybe even make it go as high as 8 armor per level (maximum 240). Lore-wise that makes sense since Undead don't have all them functioning vital organs which living folks need. Maybe even toss in "Immune to Bleeding" and possibly "Immune to Poison" as well.

There, it's a logical racial which does not remove Zombie from those who do like gimmick runs, and it does not cripple the entire race for those who do not.

Last edited by Stabbey; 26/05/17 03:09 PM. Reason: up to 8 armor per level
Joined: Oct 2016
journeyman
Offline
journeyman
Joined: Oct 2016
Or something brutally obvious:
"Undead cannot consume food or potions. They also take damage from blessed ground/areas."

I don't see an issue with normal healing magic, as it would just be restoring bones.

If we want to be super nitpicky, Skeletons should be immune to every debuff but burning and frozen.
+ Electricity only stuns living beings because it interferes with the signals generated by the action potentials sent through the nerve fibers. (Biomedical mumbo jumbo) Skeletons are clearly immune to this.
+ Poison and Bleeding are obvious.
+ Decaying: What would be decaying? Bones? Not how that works.
+ Blind: How do you blind something without eyes?

Last edited by Fluffington; 26/05/17 02:58 AM.
Joined: Nov 2016
enthusiast
Offline
enthusiast
Joined: Nov 2016
I actually really like stabbey's idea. Don't auto-give skeletons / the undead zombie, but instead give them auto armor. It's both sick as hell, and in theory allows holy fire to heal my undead warrior.

http://i.imgur.com/4kEMsvo.jpg


Link Copied to Clipboard
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5