I'm about two hours in. I've been playing couch coop on PC with two Xbox 360 controllers. I play as player one, and I've been having this extremely annoying issue where buttons don't seem to be responding correctly. It's like they aren't pressed.

Since I'm still early in the game I keep getting tutorial popups. It takes me an average of like 20 seconds to hold A to say "understood" because the game doesn't recognize that it's being pushed. Similar thing with holding B to end the turn. Or really anywhere.. Reading the log, going through menus... But not when walking around.

Second player doesn't have this issue. Changing controllers or restarting the game doesn't fix the problem. It's always first player. I would like to play this game but this is extremely annoying!

I'm not sure what to Google to fix this either. I've found nothing. Any ideas?