Yeah I did that, I just would have liked a more official ending towards that path.
Agreed, it's not the most satisfying quest outcome ever; then again, this quest really is about choosing the lesser evil, and BOTH NPCs... well, let's say, lack charisma. On the one hand you have the xenophobic zealot and loose cannon, on the other hand you have an actual cannibal psychopath. So the outcome not being all rainbows and unicorns should have been expected (by myself as well, just saying). Who knows what comes out of (y)our decision. I certainly don't feel happy about it, either way, I just tend to think that the psychopath is slightly less *Mordin-sniff* problematic than that militaristic religious nut.